will a 24-105mm lens hood work on a 10-22mm lens??

[harper]

hi guys as stated above i am wondering if a 24-105mm lens hood work on a 10-22mm lens. as i have just purchased a 10-22mm lens and already have the lens hood from a 24-105mm lens.

your help in this will be appreciated

[ameerat42]

I'd say not. If it has been well-engineered, then the angles of the shields would match the requirements of the lens. The overall wider lens would have zones where the hood would be less effective.

[arthurking83]

I'd say not. ...... The overall wider lens would have zones where the hood would be less effective.


And impede into the frame, especially at 10mm.

[Art Vandelay]

I highly doubt it as well.

Best off jumping on ebay. $5 or so will get you a chinese one delivered to your door.
Genuine Canon is probably $50 or $60.

[harper]

no worries thanks guys. would be great if i could swap someone lol

another question is, is a lens hood neccessary for this lens??

how many people here on this site own an ultrawide lens and use a lenshood??

[etherial]

I have both lenses, it certainly fits, but not sure about vignetting etc. I'll try it now...

[etherial]

Well, it fits on nicely. At 10mm you can just and I mean barely see the edges of the hood on the sides and bottom edges. They disappear by about 11-12mm. The recommended hood for the 10-22mm is an EW-83E (reference here (http://www.usa.canon.com/app/pdf/lens/EFLensChart.pdf)) and the one I have (which came with the 24-105) is the EW-83H. I reckon you could give it a go.

[JM Tran]

no worries thanks guys. would be great if i could swap someone lol

another question is, is a lens hood neccessary for this lens??

how many people here on this site own an ultrawide lens and use a lenshood??


I always leave my hoods on from teles to ultra wides, just prevents things or ppl from accidentally bumping into the lens and leaving a smear or fingerprint or scratching it. I find it invaluable for protection and reducing flare etc

[harper]

thanks guys. might give it a go for the meantime but i will eventually get the correct hood for it