Personal preference on the above from people who have used them please.

I am after a carry about lens for my d60 cause I am getting tired of swapping the 18-55 and 55-200. do either of the sigmas have appreciablely better benefits over each other apart from the diff focal length.

I am worried bout losing the wide angle of the 18-28 but am looking at a 10-20 in a few months anyway so that would fill that gap if I went with the 28. Would just have to survive until then.

Price diff is only an extra $100 for the 28-300.

Thoughts