
Originally Posted by
livio
Hi Rick,
I would like to see a slightly different competition thread, One where voting requires a justification. For example in the recent wind theme I saw a number of entries where wind was not the main subject. Sure they were all great entries but not in theme. It would be really good to have to justify your marking I think the mods and the rest of us could learn a lot from that. For example a bird theme, a score of 8 would have to be justified, good focus on the bird, great framing and detail etc. A score of 4 would be because there was no bird even though the photo of a great seascape was great. I for one try and keep to the competition even though I don't enter all of them I always try to shoot something for that week something new rather than re-cycling old photos just because it is easy. I'd even be willing to collate the results and summarise the comments.
Kind Regards
Livio