PDA

View Full Version : Nikon guessing game ---



I @ M
02-10-2010, 10:14am
or if you prefer, --- brilliant scientific deduction. :D

Which Nikkor lens mounted on which Nikon body took which picture?

http://dl.dropbox.com/u/9582534/a.JPG

http://dl.dropbox.com/u/9582534/b.JPG

etherial
02-10-2010, 11:08am
I don't know the options but I will say I think the bottom is a P&S and the top is a dslr.

farmer_rob
02-10-2010, 11:55am
Top one - wide angle (<35mm) on D700, bottom 35mm on D200? (Well, at least a DX camera)

arthurking83
02-10-2010, 2:16pm
I reckon:

Top Pic: 50/1.8 +D700
Bottom Pic: 35/1.8 +D200


apertures: approx f/2.8-4.. or thereabouts.
time of day: approx 11:00AM(alternatively 1:00PM).. give or take 1/2 hour.
location: probably Lakes Entrance(reason: possible scouting/reconnaissance trip)

AHHH! I got 'em the wrong way round!.. switch top and bottom.. I'm still half a sleep!

kiwi
02-10-2010, 4:41pm
Pass, I like the colours and contrast better in the bottom shot tho

farmer_rob
02-10-2010, 4:47pm
I reckon:

Top Pic: 50/1.8 +D700
Bottom Pic: 35/1.8 +D200


apertures: approx f/2.8-4.. or thereabouts.
time of day: approx 11:00AM(alternatively 1:00PM).. give or take 1/2 hour.
location: probably Lakes Entrance(reason: possible scouting/reconnaissance trip)

AHHH! I got 'em the wrong way round!.. switch top and bottom.. I'm still half a sleep!

I'm not sure about your lens choice - the perspective is different for nominal "equivalents". I think they're stopped down a bit more too - there is quite a lot of depth of field.

bugshutter
02-10-2010, 8:15pm
I have no idea
but if the question was whats missing in the 2nd picture that sin the first, id have a better idea
cheers

jim
02-10-2010, 10:27pm
Could as easily be the same one.

I @ M
03-10-2010, 10:21am
This highly unscientific comparison purely came about because SWMBO and I had a camera and lens combination that came close to matching each other for field of view.

Both images shot as NEFs with the usual camera settings ( everything turned off in the way of sharpening, contrast and saturation etc. ) and then both had "standard" picture control applied in Capture NX.

Image #1

D700 1/800 F/6.3 ISO 200 Nikkor 35-70 F/2.8 D @48mm

Image #2

D200 1/250 F/6.3 ISO 100 Nikkor AF-S 35mm f/1.8G

Lakes Entrance 11.20 am. :D